Is Overtraining a Myth? (Real Life Examples)
This article will be addressing overtraining, and whether it’s a legitimate concern for bodybuilders; or if its effects have been sensationalized.
There is a common belief in bodybuilding that if you train a muscle for too long, or too many times (without adequate rest days); you will enter a state of overtraining.
Overtraining is a catabolic state, caused by excessive exercise. During this time cortisol levels rise, resulting in a loss of muscle tissue and an increase in subcutaneous body fat.
Bodybuilders are particularly anxious about overtraining, thus ensuring they keep their workouts short (typically under 1 hour) and will only train 1 muscle group 1-2 times per week.
Some high profile bodybuilders have voiced their opinions on overtraining. Rich Piana strongly put across his views in a 3 minute YouTube video, branding people as as “lazy” and looking for “excuses”. This was due to comments from people accusing him of overtraining, when he completed a 3 hour chest workout.
You can watch the video below:
CT Fletcher and Kali Muscle are other high profile bodybuilders who agree with Rich Piana.
- 1 The Truth
- 2 Proof: Overtraining is Exaggerated
- 3 Proof #1 – Gymnasts
- 4 Real Life Proof #2 – Prisoners
- 5 Real Life Proof #3 – Tom Platz
- 6 It IS Possible to Overtrain Your Central Nervous System
- 7 Are Bodybuilders at Risk of Overtraining?
- 8 Summary
Overtraining is largely exaggerated in bodybuilding. There is real-life evidence to suggest it’s almost impossible to overtrain a muscle directly.
However, it IS possible to overstimulate your central nervous system, resulting in chronic fatigue in the muscles (known as overtraining).
Here are some real-life examples proving it’s extremely difficult to overtrain a muscle via weight lifting.
Proof: Overtraining is Exaggerated
If overtraining was common as a result of lifting weights for long periods of time, the following real-life examples could not exist.
Proof #1 – Gymnasts
Gymnasts have some of the most aesthetically pleasing physiques in the world, with many natural bodybuilders aspiring to replicate such muscularity.
Many Olympic gymnasts started out with ectomorph body structures, possessing insignificant amounts of muscle mass. However, after years of intense training, they can now be seen with exceptionally developed biceps, deltoids and lats.
Ironically, gymnasts don’t intend to build muscle, as being heavier makes it increasingly difficult to perform their movements effectively. Instead, their objective is to be as strong as possible, without adding bulk. Muscle is structurally dense, and thus anabolic steroid scandals are virtually non-existent in gymnastics, due to AAS potentially worsening their performance.
A more common protocol for gymnasts is to take diuretic drugs (1), helping them to reduce water weight, thus giving them an unfair advantage.
Thus we know that many gymnast’s muscular physiques are natural, and the by product of the training they do.
Olympic gymnasts who compete on the rings and pommel horse have exceptionally well developed biceps, triceps, lats and deltoids; even compared to natural bodybuilders.
Thus bodybuilders may ask the following questions:
- Why is gymnastics training significantly more effective than lifting weights?
- Should bodybuilders be performing calisthenics (gymnast movements) instead?
When observing amateur gymnasts who are yet to reach elite level, they too perform calisthenic exercises regularly, however they have significantly less muscularity compared to older gymnasts at Olympic level.
Olympic gymnasts‘ training is comprised of higher training volume, exercising for more hours throughout the week. This indicates that it is not the exercise selection that is superior (compared to bodybuilding).
Instead, gymnast’s extensive training volume is likely the culprit for exceptional muscle hypertrophy.
Note: Bodybuilders also incorporate bodyweight movements (similar to gymnasts) into their training. This gives further evidence for the difference in growth being due to increases volume and TUT (time under tension).
Gymnast Volume vs Bodybuilder Volume
The average weight lifter trains arms once or twice per week. Thus giving a total of 1-2 hours of ‘volume’ for the biceps/triceps per week.
Gina Paulhus who took part in the USA olympic program, says gymnasts train for 30 hours a week (2). This correlates as 6 hours a day x 5 times a week.
Gymnasts have 6 different events to train for being: floor, pommel horse, still rings, vault, parallel bars and horizontal bar.
Out of these 6 events, 4 stand out as being particularly demanding on the upper body: pommel horse, rings, and the 2 bar events.
By subtracting 1 hour out of the gymnast schedule to allow for a warm up and warm down, this gives them 5 hours to perform six different events.
Thus practicing for 50 minutes for each event. In total the 4 demanding events that work the upper body adds up to 200 minutes = 3 hours and 20 minutes.
Multiply 3 hours 20 minutes by 5 = 16 hours of upper body per week.
In comparison, the average amount of volume a bodybuilder will train for is:
- 1 hour chest, 1 hour back, 1 hour arms, 30 minutes shoulders = 3 hours, 30 minutes
(Main muscle groups trained during a 7 day duration).
Conclusion: An Olympic gymnast’s muscles will be under tension for almost exactly 5x longer in comparison to the average weight lifter.
This gives evidence to disprove the bodybuilding theory of: training a muscle for more than 60 minutes in a workout, multiple times per week is overtraining.
Real Life Proof #2 – Prisoners
Some people have observed friends and family enter prison, and undergo exceptional physical transformations. There have been some theories as to why this is possible, but the general scientific consensus is unknown as to why prisoners experience such dramatic transformations.
Note: Some inmates do experience tremendous amounts of muscle growth due to them obtaining anabolic steroids inside. However, other prisoners also testify to getting muscular naturally. It’s common for family members and close friends of convicts to relay that the person didn’t take any drugs, with utmost confidence.
Prisoners are often on nutrient-deprived diets, with low amounts of calories and protein. They are unlikely to have access to natural supplements and have limited access to the “weights” room, depending on the prison.
How Do Prisoners Build So Much Muscle?
The reason why some prisoners undergo dramatic body transformations (without the presence of steroids), is due to the principle of high volume training/time under tension.
Although they don’t have ‘weights’ in their cells, prisoners still find ways to stimulate muscle growth from their rooms with exercises such as:
- Doing curls with a five gallon jugs filled with water.
- Different variations of pushups: including standard, diamond, elevated, one handed and clap.
- Pull-ups/chin ups may be possible (holding onto metal water pipes).
- Dips – using the edge of the bed.
- Bodyweight squats/lunges
Bodybuilders can also perform these exercises in the gym, however the difference is prisoners have all day to workout.
For example, Charles Bronson, says in his book, Solitairy Fitness, that he did 2,000 pushups every day.
With the average weight lifter performing 1 hour of chest a week. At least, 30 minutes of that session is likely to consist of rest; leaving 30 minutes for actual exercise.
If 2 seconds per repetition is assumed (1 second for the concentric motion of the lift and 1 second for the eccentric).
Thus 30 minutes divided by 2 seconds (1 rep), means that the average weight lifter will complete 900 repetitions for chest per week.
Thus if Charles Bronson and other inmates were performing 14,000 repetitions a week for chest, and the average weight lifter is doing 900 repetitions. Prisoners like Bronson are doing up to 16x more reps.
There is a clear trend here: the more time a muscle is being worked, the bigger it grows.
Real Life Proof #3 – Tom Platz
It is widely believed that Tom Platz had the greatest legs in bodybuilding history, resembling tree trunks.
Coincidentally he is reported to have leg workouts, which consisted of 3-4 hours of squats (3).
Platz also had incredible leg strength, reportedly squatting 227.5kg for 23 reps. He admits that this strength was the result of training with lighter weights and performing higher repetitions (4).
His training philosophy of high volume/maximizing time under tension, provides more evidence that such a methodology is capable of producing exceptional muscle growth/strength. Tom Platz’s legs would have been working for 2-3x longer performing 23 reps, compared to the standard 6-10 bodybuilding rep range.
Other examples of high volume training producing significant muscle growth are: mechanic’s forearms, dancer’s calves, cyclist’s calves and a gorilla’s arms.
With the last example, a gorilla’s arms look equally as big as their legs. Our theory as to why they have different proportions to humans in this regard, is because they use all four limbs to walk throughout the day – thus creating a similar amount of time under tension for their legs and arms.
Such time under tension by walking on their arms (plus other physical exercise throughout the day), may be part of the reason why they have six times more power in their upper body compared to humans (5), and exceptional muscularity.
Some may argue that gorillas have vastly different DNA and genetics, but in reality human genetics are 98% identical to a gorilla’s (6).
It IS Possible to Overtrain Your Central Nervous System
Overtraining is certainly real, despite being over-exaggerated in bodybuilding.
When a bodybuilder lifts weights, it stimulates the central nervous system, producing higher levels of adrenaline and cortisol.
The higher stress hormones rise in the body, the more fatigued your muscles will become. This decreases your ability to recover, and increases the risk of overtraining; whereby performance suffers.
Stephen from BuiltLean.com made an interesting analogy regarding your CNS and overtraining:
Overreaching vs Overtraining
Overreaching essentially is a mild form of overtraining, when an athlete becomes fatigued and performance decreases. Overreaching typically diminishes following a few days of rest (7).
Overtraining is more severe, caused by excessive exercise, in regards to intensity and duration. Full recovery from overtraining can take several weeks or months.
Here are some common symptoms of overtraining:
- Elevated resting heart rate (evidence of high adrenaline levels).
- Dehydrated. This is because the body is catabolic, often causing a dry mouth.
- Insomnia. Not being able to sleep is a common symptom of overtraining, as the nervous system is excessively stimulated, making it increasingly difficult to switch off.
- Depression. High levels of cortisol in the blood stream means less testosterone and serotonin production. Testosterone, the male anabolic hormone, greatly impacts well-being. Serotonin also is a neutotransmitter present in the brain, responsible for feelings of happiness.
- Anxiety. Cortisol causes the body to enter “fight or flight” mode. Because overtraining causes an excessively aroused state, people may start to perceive harmless situations as threats; causing anxiety.
- Moody/Irritable. Higher cortisol levels can elicit negative mood changes. This is the same principle why people often become irritable when they haven’t eaten a meal for a long period of time.
- Becoming ill. This is a sign of a weakened immune system.
If overtraining is severe and the person doesn’t stop exercising, this can eventually result in the immune system becoming frail. Furthermore, a weakened immune system can increase the chances of cancer or other serious illnesses developing developing.
Thus overtraining (when experienced in its true form) can be dangerous if rest isn’t taken.
Cortisol also increases blood pressure, increasing the chances of heart attack or stroke. This has resulted in cortisol being nicknamed the ‘death hormone’.
Tip: Anyone experiencing symptoms of overreaching or overtraining may benefit from supplementing with 1000mg of vitamin C per day, which has shown to slash cortisol levels significantly (8).
Are Bodybuilders at Risk of Overtraining?
The typical bodybuilder is at very low risk of overtraining, with it being one of the few sports in the world where the duration of exercise is minimal.
Those who typically at risk of overtraining are professional athletes, in sports that require several hours of training each day (at high intensities). Although professional athlete’s bodies have gradually adapted to handle such workloads over time, they can still become overtrained, if a sudden increase in workload or intensity occurs.
Although lifting weights can stimulate the central nervous system, the average bodybuilder only trains for 1 hour each day. Thus cortisol levels will not rise to excessive levels.
Soothing a stimulated CNS, may allow athletes to train for longer periods without becoming overtrained.
If an athlete has a lot of stimulants in their diet such as Coca-cola, coffee, energy drinks, pre workout supplements, sugary foods/drinks, then they may be at a higher risk of overtraining.
This is due to the heart having to work harder at rest, and thus recovery is negatively impacted.
Equally, there are certain foods and drinks that are effective in calming the CNS and reducing adrenaline levels, including:
The above foods/drinks are rich in l-tryptophan, an amino acid which soothes the nervous system, reducing adrenaline production.
L-tryptophan is the reason why many people enter a post-Christmas dinner slump, often resulting in a short sleep. This is due to turkey containing l-tryptophan. Research has shown that consuming carbohydrates with l-tryptophan, increases its absorption. Potatoes aid this process, also being included in Christmas dinners.
The quantity of food a person eats can also affect the CNS. Being in a calorie deficit has shown to increase cortisol levels considerably (9). Whilst eating in a calorie surplus produces a sedative effect on the nervous system, reducing the chances of overtraining.
Lack of sleep can also increase the chances of overtraining. The recommended sleep duration is 7-9 hours (10). If sleep is compromised then you can experience a cortisol increase by as much as 45% (11).
In this article we concluded that overtraining is somewhat common in elite athletes, however very rare in bodybuilding. This is due to minimal time spent lifting weights by modern bodybuilders.
Overreaching in bodybuilding remains possible, should stress hormones such as cortisol become excessively elevated, through a severe lack of food or/and sleep.
However, assuming a bodybuilder achieves a normal duration of sleep, eats adequate amounts of food and is under normal levels of stress; overtraining is extremely unlikely.
From real-life observations it’s seemingly impossible or extremely difficult, to directly overtrain a muscle from lifting weights.
This is why gymnasts, prisoners and others are able to train the same muscle groups for hours each day with extraordinary results.